Report rules out Pakistan-India nuclear war | World Defense

Report rules out Pakistan-India nuclear war

Hithchiker

MEMBER
Joined
Nov 19, 2017
Messages
610
Reactions
727 28
Country
Pakistan
Location
Saudi Arabia
https://www.dawn.com/news/1373101/report-rules-out-pakistan-india-nuclear-war
WASHINGTON: South Asian experts reject the nuclear pessimism in Western capitals about their region, noting that the West’s nuclear “sky is falling” in South Asia argument does not hold when seen in proper context.

This is the conclusion of a report by a prestigious Washington think-tank, the Atlantic Council, which also rules out the possibility of a nuclear war between India and Pakistan.

The council based these findings on a series of seminars it held recently in New Delhi, Islamabad and Beijing, noting that South Asian experts who participated in these meetings were more optimistic than the “nuclear sky is falling” arguments often aired in the mass media, and policy conferences in general.

The experts argued that China, India and Pakistan, despite being enmeshed in a complex rivalry, “are stakeholders in the existing international order, and are committed to an open economic order and multilateral institutionalism”.

The experts also noted that all three countries were embedded in a global order that’s vastly different from either the pre-World War I era or the “first nuclear age” that was manifested during the Cold War.

“The nuclear ‘sky is falling’ argument is simply not supported by the evidence, at least when evidence is embedded in its proper context,” the experts maintain.

The report, however, warned that the greatest threat to stability in the region “comes not from the development of large, sophisticated and diversified nuclear arsenals, but from the continued stability of the institutions guarding them”.

The experts highlighted the consequences of “aggressive nationalism” in China and India, and the potential for the “the first three decades of the post-Cold War era” to become merely “a temporary hiatus in their onward nuclear journey”, which could lead to “truly horrendous” consequences that would prove true the “worst-case assumptions of the nuclear pessimists”.

The report noted that until recently, the threat of a nuclear war was thought most likely in South Asia, where India and Pakistan are involved in a festering low-intensity conflict fostered by deep conflicts about identity and territory.

The report underlined two specific dangers: Pakistan deploying tactical nuclear weapons in a conventional war with India, and India’s investments in ballistic missile defences (BMD) and multiple re-entry vehicle (MRV) technology, which gives New Delhi a first-strike option against Pakistan.

The report noted that China, India and Pakistan also share a common institutional legacy of civilian dominated nuclear decision-making structures, in which the military is only one partner, and a relatively junior one, among a host of others.

“All three factors — the structural, the normative, and the institutional — dampen both countries’ drives toward trigger-ready, destabilising, operational nuclear postures that lean toward splendid first-strike options,” it added.

The report noted that “Pakistan has developed tactical nuclear weapons, although it does not appear to have operationalised tactical nuclear warfare”.

On a positive note, the report added, neither India nor Pakistan was conducting nuclear tests to develop or improve designs for nuclear warheads. The same holds for China.

Published in Dawn, November 27th, 2017

PS: Thanks GOD reading an article where nuclear war is ruled out, I agreed to most of the points except the last as in case of Pakistan "Junior partner is opposite to what mentioned in an article"..
An agreement between Pakistan , India and China of not to fight any war for next 50 years will change the internal dynamics of each country along with external outlook being hostage to perceive threats based on past..
 

Scorpion

THINK TANK: SENIOR
Joined
Nov 27, 2014
Messages
3,739
Reactions
3,007 37
Country
Saudi Arabia
Location
Saudi Arabia
Tension will keep on going till Kashmir gets independence, India stop supporting terrorism in Pakistan and Afghanistan. The use of nukes is highly unlikely in case of war. Both countries understand the consequences on the entire region. India will be effected by its own use of nuclear attack. Radioactivity is uncontrollable.
 

I.R.A

MEMBER
Joined
Nov 21, 2017
Messages
665
Reactions
1,343 75
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Tension will keep on going till Kashmir gets independence, India stop supporting terrorism in Pakistan and Afghanistan. The use of nukes is highly unlikely in case of war. Both countries understand the consequences on the entire region. India will be effected by its own use of nuclear attack. Radioactivity is uncontrollable.
And you don't have India and Pakistan only in the region ........ such a clash would be catastrophic for many nations and more than half the population of this world. Nearly the whole world would suffer if ever we go crazy.
 

Hithchiker

MEMBER
Joined
Nov 19, 2017
Messages
610
Reactions
727 28
Country
Pakistan
Location
Saudi Arabia
Tension will keep on going till Kashmir gets independence, India stop supporting terrorism in Pakistan and Afghanistan. The use of nukes is highly unlikely in case of war. Both countries understand the consequences on the entire region. India will be effected by its own use of nuclear attack. Radioactivity is uncontrollable.
Though agreed...The major root cause in Kashmir..
 

Top