Sea Sultan - PN Selected Embraer Lineage 1000E Jetliner for LRMPA | Page 2 | World Defense

Sea Sultan - PN Selected Embraer Lineage 1000E Jetliner for LRMPA

Scorpio

THINK TANK
Joined
Jan 14, 2020
Messages
1,432
Reactions
8 2,676 59
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
We recently inducted TPS 70 MRR radars that will make up the backbone of PAKADGE for years to come.
Army operates M109 SPs, TPS36 Firefinders, M198 155m howitzers, M113 APCs just to name a few systems.

Per @Khafee new /EDA C-130j on the way as well as f-sola :)
But positive side now we also start looking inducting Chinese or non American alternative as well... hopefully it will increase time that time i e
More primary Chinese fighter jet
AWACS from saab
Warship from china and turkey
Italian and russian helos
Chinese subs
So on . .... ....
 

Mingle

MEMBER
Joined
Sep 4, 2019
Messages
962
Reactions
1 1,562 5
Country
Pakistan
Location
Canada
But positive side now we also start looking inducting Chinese or non American alternative as well... hopefully it will increase time that time i e
More primary Chinese fighter jet
AWACS from saab
Warship from china and turkey
Italian and russian helos
Chinese subs
So on . .... ....
True with US india BECA deal Pak should start looking alternatives like Navy pivots from US hardware so PAF start looking towards that direction I believe after this deal I see more Russian hardware into Armed forces of Pak
 

Scorpio

THINK TANK
Joined
Jan 14, 2020
Messages
1,432
Reactions
8 2,676 59
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
True with US india BECA deal Pak should start looking alternatives like Navy pivots from US hardware so PAF start looking towards that direction I believe after this deal I see more Russian hardware into Armed forces of Pak
Problem with russian arms they want hard cash upfront... which we lacks always
 
Joined
Oct 11, 2019
Messages
380
Reactions
10 1,382 60
Country
USA
Location
USA
They should to the upgrade/retrofit @ PAC Kamra with Embraer's input. PAC has shown that it does have capability of undertaking such projects when it salvaged AEW Radar/electronics from damaged Erieye's and installed them on new platforms.
Yes PAC did a great job with SAAB AWACS...
...but in that case Pak had working examples of those...and IIRC they got some assistance from SAAB...

Pak doesn't have much history(besides that SAAB example) in this particular matter(like integrating subsystems on a jet). Also considering the fact that this would be the first time for this type of particular jet...
...Pak doing it could run the risk of cost overruns.

It would be better to take a safer approach. If possible...Pak can maybe get assistance from RAS...and work out some kind of a deal...where Pak gets the ability to do it locally. So they do like 1 or 2...and then rest are done in Pak...and Pak "owns" it(the process/method of integrating subsystems)
...so if other countries are interested...Pak can do it for them and make some money(in addition to saving costs by doing the rest of them in house for PN...and gaining knowledge that would help in the future).

...just my 2 cents
 

Gripen9

THINK TANK
Joined
Sep 5, 2019
Messages
1,207
Reactions
19 4,502 174
Country
Pakistan
Location
USA
Yes PAC did a great job with SAAB AWACS...
...but in that case Pak had working examples of those...and IIRC they got some assistance from SAAB...

Pak doesn't have much history(besides that SAAB example) in this particular matter(like integrating subsystems on a jet). Also considering the fact that this would be the first time for this type of particular jet...
...Pak doing it could run the risk of cost overruns.

It would be better to take a safer approach. If possible...Pak can maybe get assistance from RAS...and work out some kind of a deal...where Pak gets the ability to do it locally. So they do like 1 or 2...and then rest are done in Pak...and Pak "owns" it(the process/method of integrating subsystems)
...so if other countries are interested...Pak can do it for them and make some money(in addition to saving costs by doing the rest of them in house for PN...and gaining knowledge that would help in the future).

...just my 2 cents
You are right. However PAC had zero experience when it embarked of Erieye restoration project. From a conversation with someone at PAC, I was given the impression that PAC had reached out to PN when they were doing the ATR conversion and PN was not interested in PAC's involvement.
I sure hope there is some sort of local involvement.
 
Joined
Oct 11, 2019
Messages
380
Reactions
10 1,382 60
Country
USA
Location
USA
You are right. However PAC had zero experience when it embarked of Erieye restoration project. From a conversation with someone at PAC, I was given the impression that PAC had reached out to PN when they were doing the ATR conversion and PN was not interested in PAC's involvement.
I sure hope there is some sort of local involvement.
I'm also hoping for local involvement...
...hell if we could do it without cost overruns(like if Pak had RAS kind of experience under its belt)...that would be awesome. I have no doubt that other countries would eventually place orders for this too(P3 is quite commonly used...and Sea Sultan would be a great alternative) and Pak would be able to make money.

However Pak can hardly afford cost overruns for a project as big as 10 LRMPAs. My guess is that Pak will be acquiring these little by little(kind of like how PN acquired the ATR MPAs)...
...bcuz Pak cannot dish out the money altogether for all 10. This is why any mishap in the estimated costs(of conversion) and it can shake up the whole planned 10 LRMPAs.

If Pak could sort of come to some agreement...with RAS or some Turkish firm(that has extensive experience in this)...where they do it for Pak...but have PAC's involvement for the first 1 or 2...then PAC does the rest...that would be a safer option. Starting with PAC from the get go...would be more experimental than starting with RAS imo. If Pak was a rich country...we could afford such luxury and it would be a great learning experience...but that's not the case. One of the potential reasons PN refused PAC could be bcuz PN has a lot in the pipeline and can't afford to take risks since it has very little wiggle room with the money available.
 

BATMAN

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Dec 20, 2017
Messages
1,207
Reactions
8 1,203 35
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Most probably nice kickbacks from RAS :)

I had asked someone at PAC when PN was doing the ATR conversion. And he just laughed, and said Navy likes to do things on their own alluding to the fact that PAC had proposed something like this to be done in house....
100% correct.
 
Top