Chill Republic

[Pakhtoon yum]

Given the level of education, studying two langugaes for the masses might be a big issue. Emphasis should be on a national language, with regional language as optional.

Some languages are dying out though that's why I was saying to educate them in both. Or pakistan is still young and it should drop urdu and pick up farsi again.

Farsi was already spoken in pakistan before the Brits and even after independence but some idiot decided on urdu as the national language.

 

[Khafee]

Some languages are dying out though that's why I was saying to educate them in both. Or pakistan is still young and it should drop urdu and pick up farsi again.

Farsi was already spoken in pakistan before the Brits and even after independence but some idiot decided on urdu as the national language.

Well if one were to go totally of on a tangent, then Arabic would have been better.

 

[Pakhtoon yum]

Well if one were to go totally of on a tangent, then Arabic would have been better.

Arabic doesnt have any cultural roots in our country farsi does. So nope

Although if it does become Arabic then pakistan would dominate the middle east, especially the Arab countries

 

[Khafee]

Arabic doesnt have any cultural roots in our country farsi does. So nope

Those roots are long dead and gone, besides irani lovers, only a minority. So if you want to enforce your views, you are going to need a stronger reason than this.

 

[Pakhtoon yum]

Those roots are long dead and gone, besides irani lovers, only a minority. So if you want to enforce your views, you are going to need a stronger reason than this.

Arabic has also been advanced in science which we could pick up advance on. It would be hard to Crest new words in urdu for them. If you know what I mean.

You are right though, arabic would be more influential and beneficial then farsi now. From Pakistan's entertainment industry to business would increase dramatically.

 

[Zeeman]

Yes Arabic would be a lot more beneficial for Pakistanis. But that said there is no language superior in literature and poetry than Farsi.

My grandfather wrote poetry in Farsi and could read and understand Arabic .

Urdu has a lot of Farsi and Turkish words as well as Arabic .

 

[!eon]

@!eon you sound insecure accusing everyone calling you a traitor....well are you?

Ahh Really? Where you found accusing everyone calling me a traitor?
I am waiting for you find that accusation of mine and @Khafee may help you in that, because he liked what you said.

 

[!eon]

Hes making a mountain out of a hill

Depends on you, with your knowledge you can turn a mountain into a sand grain and with your ignorance, when you have no answer, every molehill is mountain for you.

 

[!eon]

You are the one who keeps bringing loyalty into the discussion.

Because that's directly proportional to digestion of "national" language "in Pakistan".

Not a healthy question? Then what about this one?

Are you one of them that cannot digest Urdu as a national language?

 

[!eon]

Given the level of education, studying two langugaes for the masses might be a big issue. Emphasis should be on a national language, with regional language as optional.

National language on what basis?

 

[!eon]

Simple fix is making learning regional languages a mandatory subject in each district. From KG to university.

Fix for what? What is the problem?

 

[!eon]

Arabic doesnt have any cultural roots in our country farsi does. So nope

How can you say that, Farsi has cultural roots and Arabic has none?
From which city you are tell me and I would tell you how much roots Arabic has and how much Farsi, exactly in your city.

 

[Gripen9]

Because that's directly proportional to digestion of "national" language "in Pakistan".

Not a healthy question? Then what about this one?

I was quoting you.

 

[Pakhtoon yum]

How can you say that, Farsi has cultural roots and Arabic has none?
From which city you are tell me and I would tell you how much roots Arabic has and how much Farsi, exactly in your city.

You sure do talk big
How abt the fact that all pakistani languages are heavily influenced by Persian and Persian being the lingua franca far before any arabic was spoken in these lands.


@Khafee do check his other posts regarding my comment on his insecurities, his instructions not mine

 

[!eon]

I was quoting you.

It gave me an opportunity to scratch a blasphemous issue.